Front row seat to OJ Simpson’s fall, rise, fall
LOS ANGELES (AP) — O.J. Simpson stood up from the counsel table at his murder trial and approached the jury box with the famous leather gloves. As he struggled to get them past his knuckles, he held his hands up to jurors and stated the obvious: “They’re too small.”
Next to me in the front row of the courtroom 20 years ago sat writer Dominick Dunne, who came to the trial believing the U.S. football hero was guilty of killing his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend Ronald Goldman. But in that moment the playing field had changed.
“Did you see that?” Dunne whispered. “He took those gloves and he ran with them as if he was running down a football field. This case is over.”
That moment from Simpson’s “Trial of the Century” lives on in my memory.
I called prosecutor Chris Darden at the day’s end, asking why he had Simpson try on the gloves.
“What did it look like to you?” he asked me.
“It looked like they didn’t fit,” I said.
“Well,” Darden said, “I looked at his hands and I looked at the gloves and I thought they would fit.”
Darden had violated a cardinal rule of courtroom law: Don’t demonstrate something in front of a jury unless you know the outcome.
That day, Simpson’s charismatic lawyer, Johnnie Cochran, coined a phrase that would become an enduring motto in pop culture: “If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit.”
There would be months more testimony, but that was a turning point. It was June 15, 1995, a year and two days after the slashed bodies of Nicole Simpson and Goldman had been found outside her home.
Police said they found a bloody glove at the scene and many hours later a lone police detective, Mark Fuhrman, scaled a wall outside O.J. Simpson’s house and said he found a match. Now, the gloves appeared not to fit the suspect, and the credibility of Fuhrman would be irrevocably damaged when tapes revealed him making disparaging remarks about black people.
Were the gloves planted? Was it a setup? Those questions would haunt the case forever.
No knife was located, and there were no bloody clothes at Simpson’s home. DNA evidence was compromised by shoddy police work.
Lead prosecutor Marcia Clark, who was watching her case fall apart, came to my courthouse office one morning and asked, “Do you think we even have a chance?”
In the intervening year, the sports and movie star had been transformed in the public mind from national treasure to murder defendant.
He was acquitted. But from hindsight of 20 years, it is clear there were few winners in the case, least of all Simpson.
Contacted through his lawyer, Simpson, who had spoken to me many times over the years, declined to be interviewed for this story. He sent word that anything he said would just result in media attacks and would be detrimental to his children.
In two decades, he has never wavered in his claim of innocence.
A civil jury, however, awarded the Brown and Goldman families $33.5 million in wrongful death damages, which the Goldmans are still trying to collect.
Simpson moved to Florida where laws benefit retirees and he could pursue his passion for golf. His private life provided tabloid fodder as he acquired a girlfriend and frequented Miami clubs. A road rage incident sent him back to court, but he was acquitted.
In 2007, while in Las Vegas for a friend’s wedding, Simpson staged a casino hotel heist of dealers trying to sell his memorabilia. The raiding party included a man with a gun, and the entire episode was secretly tape recorded.
Some saw the case as payback when Simpson was sentenced to 9 to 33 years in prison for armed robbery and kidnapping. Others got sentences as light as probation.
Two Las Vegas police detectives were overheard on tape saying: “They didn’t get him in L.A., but we’ll get him here.”
At an unsuccessful hearing seeking a new trial last year, Simpson was unrecognizable as the once trim and fit celebrity. He was bloated and graying, his arms and legs shackled to a courtroom chair. His defense continues to appeal as he is held in a Nevada prison cell.
Deutsch covered three O.J. Simpson trials in Los Angeles and Las Vegas and has interviewed him over two decades.