Leading Thai seafood boss: AP shrimp probe 'wake-up call'
Leading Thai seafood boss: AP shrimp probe 'wake-up call'
ROBIN McDOWELL & MARTHA MENDOZA
Dec. 15, 2015
BANGKOK (AP) — The president of one of the world's biggest seafood exporters expressed frustration and promised change Tuesday after saying an Associated Press investigation that linked slave-peeled shrimp to his company should be a "wake-up call" to the industry.
Thiraphong Chansiri said Thai Union will spend millions of dollars to end reliance on poorly regulated contractors that have been responsible for much of the abuse. He added that under the current system, it's almost impossible to ensure that supply chains are clean.
Like other exporters in Thailand, his company has for years relied heavily on poor migrants working in factories in the port town of Samut Sakhon to peel, gut and devein shrimp.
The AP report revealed Monday that many of these laborers are undocumented and can end up being tricked or sold into factories where they are forced to work 16-hour days with no time off and little or no pay for sometimes years at a time. Some end up locked inside. Others are allowed to go out, but only if they leave their children or spouse behind as a guarantee against running away.
Thiraphong said despite great efforts, Thai Union has been unable to keep labor abuses out of its supply chains. It has tried everything from spot checks by third-party auditors to regular meetings with external suppliers. But problems keep popping up.
"We realized that we could not ensure 100 percent," he said. "Even with the whole system that we established."
He said Thai Union will exclusively use in-house labor for shrimp processing starting Jan. 1, a change he said would cost the company about $5 million.
"This move will provide us with full oversight of all processing stages and will ensure that all workers, whether migrant or Thai, are in safe, legal employment and are treated fairly and with dignity," Thiraphong said.
A day earlier, he called the latest revelations "another wake-up call not only to us, but to the entire industry."
On Tuesday, the Global Aquaculture Alliance, which audits companies and offers a Best Aquaculture Practices seal of approval, said it will pull its certification from anyone outsourcing shrimp processing.
AP journalists followed trucks from an abusive factory raided last month to major Thai distributors, including a Thai Union subsidiary, and traced similar connections from another factory, raided in May, that was directly supplying the parent company.
Thai Union and four other exporters that bought shrimp from the sheds sell to companies around the world. Those retailers and restaurant chains widely condemned the practices that led to these conditions, and many said they were launching investigations.
Big Australian supermarket chain companies, including Coles and Woolworths, were among those that expressed concern.
Coles, Red Lobster, Whole Foods and some other companies said they had been assured by Thai Union that their shipments were clean. Thai Union said shrimp it purchased from the sheds AP tracked did not go to major U.S. companies, while declining to say where it went. In any case, according to U.S. and United Nations standards, if even a single piece of shrimp coming from a company is tied to forced labor, it taints the entire supply chain.
Some said the problem requires a drastic response from big players.
"I guarantee you that if Wal-Mart and Kroger and Red Lobster stopped buying from Thailand until this got fixed, I think pretty soon Thailand would have no choice but to really deal with it," said Buddy Galetti, president of Southwind Foods, a smaller importer in Los Angeles. He said he rarely buys Thai goods.
"The large corporations are the ones who act like the pope as far as sustainability and human rights, but then they go out and buy from the main culprits," Galetti said.
U.S. customs records show the shrimp AP tracked made its way into the supply chains of major U.S. food stores and retailers such as Wal-Mart, Kroger, Dollar General and Petco, along with restaurants such as Olive Garden.
It also entered the supply chains of some of America's best-known seafood brands and pet foods, including Chicken of the Sea and Fancy Feast, which are sold in grocery stores from Safeway and Schnucks to Piggly Wiggly and Albertsons. AP reporters went to supermarkets in all 50 states and found shrimp products from supply chains tainted with forced labor.
Earlier this year, after AP uncovered a slave island in Indonesia where fishermen were caged when on shore, Greenpeace called for a boycott of Thai Union and its Chicken of the Sea brand in the U.S. On Monday, Greenpeace campaign director John Hocevar said Thai Union isn't doing enough.
"The company does just enough to weather the PR storm while continuing to profit off the backs of the migrant workers forced to work throughout its supply chains," he said.
Thailand has said repeatedly that it's working to clean up its $7 billion seafood export industry, where abuses are fueled by corruption and police complicity. In a front-page article Tuesday in the country's biggest English-language newspaper, the Bangkok Post, Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha said the country has already been cracking down on officers who turn a blind eye to labor abuses in processing plants.
"We are dealing with the issue, aren't we?" he said. "Arrests are underway."
Most U.S. customers said they're sticking with their Thai distributors, and Gavin Gibbons, a spokesman for National Fisheries Institute, which represents about 75 percent of the U.S. seafood industry, said boycotting Thailand is not the answer.
"If you don't buy seafood from there, you're not in the conversation anymore about labor, you don't have the ability to fix it," he said.
AP's findings surprised some consumers. "I've bought bags of shrimp before at the market but never really looked at the label. I guess I should start looking, huh?" said Chris York, of Kensington, New Hampshire.
That was the advice of the U.S. State Department's new anti-trafficking ambassador Susan Coppedge. She said consumers should inform themselves, and can check the government-backed website slaveryfootprint.org and Labor Department publications before they spend "to make sure they're not made with forced slave labor."
Mendoza reported from New York; Kristen Gelineau contributed from Sydney, Australia.
Follow us on Twitter: @mendozamartha, @robinmcdowell
This story has been corrected to show that comments by Thai Union president were on Tuesday, not Wednesday.