Buttigieg removes attorney from fundraiser after backlash

October 19, 2019 GMT
Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg speaks to supporters at Iowa State University during a town hall style meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 16, 2019, in Ames, Iowa. (Bryon Houlgrave/The Des Moines Register via AP)
Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg speaks to supporters at Iowa State University during a town hall style meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 16, 2019, in Ames, Iowa. (Bryon Houlgrave/The Des Moines Register via AP)

WASHINGTON (AP) — Pete Buttigieg is returning campaign contributions from a former Chicago city attorney who led a vigorous effort to block the release of a video depicting the shooting of Laquan McDonald , a black teenager whose death at the hands of police stirred months of protest and resulted in an officer’s conviction.

The Democratic presidential candidate also removed Steve Patton as a co-sponsor of a fundraiser held in Chicago on Friday. The move came after The Associated Press reported on his involvement in the event, which provoked a fierce online backlash directed at Buttigieg.

“I believe very strongly that transparency and justice for Laquan McDonald is a lot more important than a campaign contribution,” Buttigieg said later during an interview with David Axelrod, a former adviser to President Barack Obama.

Until the uproar, Buttigieg’s campaign had declined to comment on Patton’s involvement. Patton led Chicago’s law department under former Mayor Rahm Emanuel.

For months, Buttigieg has faced criticism over his handling of race as mayor of South Bend, Indiana, a city with a history of segregation where decades of simmering tension erupted this summer when a white police officer shot and killed an African American man. Despite Buttigieg’s promise to “do better,” his handling of the fundraiser demonstrates his sometimes awkward efforts to improve his standing in the black community, which is a crucial segment of the Democratic electorate.

“He should adjust his schedule,” the Rev. Jesse Jackson said when asked about the fundraiser earlier this week and before Buttigieg’s campaign decided to cut ties with Patton.

The Chicago civil rights icon, whose guidance Buttigieg sought amid the unrest over the South Bend police shooting, said he has a high opinion of the White House hopeful but felt he “should be made aware” that Patton’s participation would be a problem.

Even before the South Bend shooting this summer, Buttigieg has struggled to address his record on race as mayor. Critics, including many residents, have blasted him for firing the city’s first black police chief shortly after taking office, for prioritizing South Bend’s downtown over its neighborhoods and for issues of housing, crime and inequality.

Patton did not respond to multiple requests for comment, and the role he played raising money for Buttigieg wasn’t entirely clear.

He gave a maximum $5,600 donation in June. A statement from campaign spokesman Chris Meagher indicated Patton tapped his own personal network to “bundle” contributions from others. While that money will be returned, Meagher did not address questions about how much Patton raised or how long he had been active as a bundler.

An invitation to a Buttigieg fundraiser held in Chicago in July shows Patton was also listed as a co-sponsor. Meagher said he couldn’t immediately comment on that event.

McDonald’s death in October 2014 , as well as efforts by police to cover up any wrongdoing, roiled the city as attention to the case grew.

Police said at the time that McDonald was armed with a knife and “lunged” at officers. But video, which was released over a year later after a judge’s order, showed the teenager veering away when officer Jason Van Dyke fired 16 shots at him. The knife he had was a pocketknife.

Van Dyke was sentenced to nearly seven years in prison and three other officers faced trial for a cover-up, though they were acquitted.

Patton faced criticism over his handling of the matter, which imperiled Emanuel’s administration and drew an all-hands-on-deck response from the then-mayor’s top aides. Patton advised against releasing the video until an investigation was concluded — and after Emanuel survived a contentious mayoral runoff reelection. Emails released by the city show he was involved in managing the fallout as media interest grew and coordinated statements with the city’s purportedly independent police oversight board.

One of Patton’s top deputies attempted to get McDonald’s family to agree to not release the footage during settlement talks, which the city entered into without the family filing suit. Patton also played a role in negotiating a $5 million sum that was far less than what McDonald’s family asked for.

The law department he oversaw was found to have withheld evidence in more than a half-dozen of police misconduct cases.

Activists say Buttigieg’s handling of the matter is his latest misstep. Over the summer, he held a fundraiser in Chicago’s historically black Bronzeville neighborhood at a center named for Harold Washington, its first black mayor, which drew a mostly white audience.

“The worst-case scenario is his people know and they just don’t care, or they don’t know and haven’t vetted him thoroughly,” said Charlene Carruthers, former head of Black Lives Matter group BYP100, which was instrumental in pushing for police reforms following the McDonald case.

“If they do know, it’s indicative of so much of what we see with folks in the LGBTQ community — particularly white men who may hold a sexual identity, but their politics don’t line up with the liberation of the people who are also in community with them.”

During his interview with Axelrod, the Obama adviser, Buttigieg said he was unaware of Patton’s role in the McDonald case until Friday morning and moved quickly to sever ties.

“This is important because it reflects on the campaign,” Buttigieg said.

Axelrod suggested his campaign was doing a poor job scrutinizing donors, despite having hundreds on staff.

“I’d hire one more and put them on vetting,” he retorted.