2012: Virginia Commonwealth 62, Wichita State 59
One year after reaching the Final Four as a No. 11 seed, VCU was back to its upsetting ways in 2012. This time, it was Wichita State who was burned by the Rams defense, which held the Shockers to just 38.7 percent shooting. VCU’s run ended prematurely, though, as the Rams lost to No. 4 seed Indiana, 63-61, in the next round.