Arrest of girl who texted in class prompts civil rights case
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A girl who refused to surrender her phone after texting in math class was flipped backward and tossed across the classroom floor by a sheriff’s deputy, prompting a federal civil rights probe on Tuesday.
The sheriff said the girl “may have had a rug burn” but was not injured, and said the teacher and vice principal felt the officer acted appropriately. Still, videos of the confrontation between a white officer and black girl stirred such outrage that he called the FBI and Justice Department for help.
Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott suspended Senior Deputy Ben Fields without pay, and said what he did at Spring Valley High School in Columbia made him want to “throw up.”
“Literally, it just makes you sick to your stomach when you see that initial video. But again, that’s a snapshot,” he said.
Videos taken by students and posted online show Fields warning the girl to leave her seat or be forcibly removed on Monday. The officer then wraps a forearm around her neck, flips her and the desk backward onto the floor, tosses her toward the front of the classroom and handcuffs her.
Lott pointed out at a news conference that the girl can also be seen trying to strike the officer as she was being taken down, but said he’s focused on the deputy’s actions as he decides within 24 hours whether Fields should remain on the force.
“I think sometimes our officers are put in uncomfortable positions when a teacher can’t control a student,” the sheriff said, promising to be fair.
Email, phone and text messages for Fields were not returned.
The deputy also arrested a second student who verbally objected to his actions. Both girls were charged with disturbing schools and released to their parents. Their names were not officially released.
The second student, Niya Kenny, told WLTX-TV that she felt she had to say something. Doris Kenny said she’s proud her daughter was “brave enough to speak out against what was going on.”
Appearing on MSNBC Tuesday night, Niya Kenny said an administrator told her to sit down, be quiet and to put her cellphone away. She refused.
″‘This is not right. This is not right,’” Kenny recalled saying in the classroom. ”‘I can’t believe y’all are doing this to her.’”
Kenny said Fields arrested her and handcuffed her inside the classroom.
Lt. Curtis Wilson told The Associated Press in an email to “keep in mind this is not a race issue.”
“Race is indeed a factor,” countered South Carolina’s NAACP president, Lonnie Randolph Jr., who praised the Justice Department for agreeing to investigate.
“To be thrown out of her seat as she was thrown, and dumped on the floor ... I don’t ever recall a female student who is not of color (being treated this way). It doesn’t affect white students,” Randolph said.
The sheriff, for his part, said race won’t factor into his evaluation: “It really doesn’t matter to me whether that child had been purple,” Lott said.
Tony Robinson Jr., who recorded the final moments, said it all began when the teacher asked the girl to hand over her phone during class. She refused, so he called an administrator, who summoned the officer.
“The administrator tried to get her to move and pleaded with her to get out of her seat,” Robinson told WLTX. “She said she really hadn’t done anything wrong. She said she took her phone out, but it was only for a quick second, you know, please, she was begging, apologetic.”
“Next, the administrator called Deputy Fields in. ... He asked, ‘Will you move?’ and she said ‘No, I haven’t done anything wrong,’” Robinson said.
“When I saw what was going to happen, my immediate first thing to think was, let me get this on camera. This was going to be something ... that everyone else needs to see, something that we can’t just let this pass by.”
Districts across the country put officers in schools after teenagers massacred fellow students at Columbine High School in Colorado in 1999. Schools now routinely summon police to discipline students, experts say.
“Kids are not criminals, by the way. When they won’t get up, when they won’t put up the phone, they’re silly, disobedient kids — not criminals,” said John Whitehead, founder of the Rutherford Institute, a nonprofit civil liberties and human rights organization.
Police should guard doors to “stop the crazies from getting in these schools,” Whitehead said, but “when you have police in the schools, you’re going to run into this — having police do what teachers and parents should do.”
The National Association of School Resource Officers recommends that schools and police agree to prohibit officers “from becoming involved in formal school discipline situations that are the responsibility of school administrators.”
At a school board meeting Tuesday night, parents spoke out about the arrest.
“This is not a race issue,” said Rebekah Woodford, a white mother of two Spring Valley graduates and one current student. “This is, ‘I want to be defiant and not do what I’m told.’ ... The child is the one who can choose what to do.”
School Superintendent Debbie Hamm said “the district will not tolerate any actions that jeopardize the safety of our students.” School Board Chairman Jim Manning called the deputy’s actions “shamefully shocking.”
Fields, who also coaches football at the high school, has prevailed against accusations of excessive force and racial bias before.
Trial is set for January in the case of an expelled student who claims Fields targeted blacks and falsely accused him of being a gang member in 2013. In another case, a federal jury sided with Fields after a black couple accused him of excessive force and battery during a noise complaint arrest in 2005. A third lawsuit, dismissed in 2009, involved a woman who accused him of battery and violating her rights during a 2006 arrest.
Contributors include Martha Waggoner in Raleigh, North Carolina. Kinnard can be reached at http://twitter.com/MegKinnardAP .